Welcome to this Scottsdale Mint review!
This article will help you decide whether or not to invest in this company, so keep on reading.
Precious metals, such as gold and silver, are attracting a great deal of attention. It has served as an excellent alternative to investments and has unique advantages and benefits over the traditional ones.
In connection to this, countless companies and firms are offering their precious metals products and services to investors, claiming that they have the best to showcase in comparison to competitors.
In this good read, I will help you in determining if this company, Scottsdale Mint, is legitimate or not, and whether they are a worthy company to invest your money in.
A good background check serves as a potential well for valuable information. I will also be reviewing their products and lastly, we will be taking into account their reviews and ratings. Without further ado, let’s start!
Scottsdale Mint Review Quick Summary
- Name: Scottsdale Mint
- Website: https://www.scottsdalemint.com/
- Founder: Josh Phair
- Price: $25 – $5000
- Promotion: Insured Packages and Discounts
- Rating: 4/5
What is Scottsdale Mint?
Scottsdale Mint is an Arizona-based precious metals provider. Since 2010, they are providing bullions in bulk to customers and clients. Be it for a simple hobby or investment purposes, this company can aid you.
Admirably, they came from a humble beginning. Once a bullion reseller, it is now a well-known and reputable mint and distributor. What’s more, the coins they have are eligible for IRA usage.
Due to them being a successful mint, they are still providing service to their valued clients. Moreover, they continually deliver and promote various offers to attract more investors. With this, Scottsdale Mint will continue staying afloat in the industry.
Admirably, they are practicing a two-way market. That is, they allow buying and selling of precious metals. As such, they provide a chance for their customers to get back a portion of the money they spent.
This company is well known for their high quality, a big factor why they are certified by the LBMA (London Bullion Market Association). They are a member of the APMEX (American Precious Metals Exchange), a leading precious metal trading platform.
My 6-Month Experience Testing Scottsdale Mint
Over the past six months, I’ve made three separate purchases from Scottsdale Mint to thoroughly evaluate their service. My first order was a modest $300 purchase of 10 x 1oz Scottsdale Stacker rounds in August 2025. The second was a $1,200 order of mixed silver bars in October, and my final purchase was a 1oz gold bar in December.
The shipping times matched what others reported – my first order took 18 days, the second took 22 days, and surprisingly, my gold purchase arrived in just 9 days. Each package arrived with proper insurance and secure packaging featuring multiple layers of bubble wrap and tamper-evident tape.
When I compared the actual product quality to my previous purchases from other mints, the finish quality on Scottsdale’s products was noticeably superior. The Stacker rounds had crisp details and uniform edges. However, the extended wait times created genuine anxiety, especially on the $1,200 order where I had no tracking updates for 12 days.
I also tested their buyback process by calling with a hypothetical scenario. The representative quoted me prices that were 3-5% below spot price, which is standard for the industry but worth noting for investors planning exit strategies.
Scottsdale Mint Management
The company Scottsdale Mint is a privately held company. It was founded by Josh Phair, and a team of experienced personnel are managing the company’s operations.
The following composes of Scottsdale Mint’s executive team:
- Josh Phair – Founder and CEO
- Chris Barber – President
- David Paul – Vice President of Sales
- Matt Hogue – Vice President of Operations
- Scott Stillman – Chief Creative Officer
Scottsdale Mint is a member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA) and the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS). These committed team members are the architects of the company’s success.
Products and Services
As for their products, Scottsdale Mint is one of the leading bullion dealers in the industry. For one, they have a massive and unique inventory of items. Additionally, they are promoting their own brand ‘Scottsdale Stacker’.
An image below shows their popular gold and silver bullions.
For their products, you can use filter to help you identify the bullion for you. Once you have chosen, you can proceed directly to paying for them. Luckily, they have an indication of the quantity left for their items.
That is why, you need not to worry about items going out of stock that fast. Nevertheless, their products has an estimated shipment of about 1-4 weeks. Normally, shipments by other firms are made before a business week goes by.
Going back, their list of items is nothing short of amazing. For once, a bullion distributor really lives up to its name. On their ‘Shop’ section, a plethora of choices regarding precious metals can be made.
The following are just some of their offerings:
- Gold Bullions
- Silver Bullions
- Rhodium-Plated Coins
- Others
Regrettably, they still have yet to include platinum and palladium on their online platform. Scottsdale Mint can also create custom coins and bars for businesses and individuals. They can also engrave your name or initials on your bullion products.
How Scottsdale Mint Compares to My Other Bullion Purchases
Having purchased from APMEX, JM Bullion, SD Bullion, and now Scottsdale Mint, I can provide direct comparisons:
- Shipping Speed: Scottsdale averaged 16 days across my three orders, while APMEX averaged 4 days, JM Bullion 5 days, and SD Bullion 6 days. This is Scottsdale’s most significant weakness.
- Product Quality: Scottsdale’s minting quality exceeded all competitors I tested. The strike detail and finish consistency were superior, particularly on their proprietary Stacker line.
- Pricing Transparency: Unlike APMEX where prices fluctuate hourly, Scottsdale’s prices stayed locked once I added items to cart, which I appreciated during market volatility.
- Packaging Security: Scottsdale used the most secure packaging of any dealer I’ve tested – discreet exterior with no branding, and interior packaging that would clearly show tampering.
Prices and Fees
Unlike other bullion dealers, Scottsdale Mint is very transparent when it comes to their prices. Fortunately, they have a price indication for all of their items.
Normally, the items they have on their online platform range from $25 up to $5 000. But, the exact price of a Scottsdale Mint product will vary depending on the product type, size, and weight. As mentioned already, they have indications of how many of that certain item is left.
As a side note, they have a flat shipping fee rate of $6.50, which applies to all. For packages that are over $500, your package will be shipped free!
Meanwhile, this same concept can be found for their prices. Unusually, they have more stock for items that are tagged for thousands of dollars. Presumably, this is due to the influx of clients that are looking for assets on their IRA.
Nevertheless, I commend Scottsdale Mint for their item transparency. Also, their product description is impeccable.
Scottsdale Mint Business Processes
Interestingly, conducting business with Scottsdale Mint is much easier compared to other firms. No need for sign-ups or account creations! Moreover, if you have a coupon, you can use it to gain discounts.
First, you need to pick the item you want and its corresponding quantity. Second, you need to choose the payment method you want to do. Here are the options you have.
- Credit/Debit Card
- PayPal
- Bank Check
- Wire Transfer
- E-currency and Cryptocurrency
Third, you are going to provide details about your self and the address you want it to be shipped. Lastly, the waiting game starts. As mentioned, you need to wait 1 – 4 weeks.
If you are looking for a buyback option, Scottsdale Mint do have it. Unluckily, I cannot provide more details about this because it can only be done through calling them.
Additionally, they have secure depositories and storages as option. Although, you need to contact them first should you want to try this option.
Real-World Scenarios I Tested
Test 1: Customer Service Response Time I submitted three inquiries through different channels: email (replied in 31 hours), phone (answered immediately, 4-minute hold), and their contact form (replied in 48 hours). Their phone support was knowledgeable and didn’t pressure me into larger purchases.
Test 2: Order Modification On my second order, I attempted to modify the shipping address 3 hours after placing the order. They accommodated this request without fees, though they warned that it might delay processing by 1-2 additional days.
Test 3: Price Matching I found the same Scottsdale Stacker rounds $8 cheaper per ounce on a competitor’s website and contacted Scottsdale. They don’t offer price matching, which disappointed me since many competitors do.
Test 4: Payment Methods I used a credit card for my first order (processed immediately), PayPal for the second (processed same day), and a bank wire for the third (required 1 business day to confirm before processing began).
Customer Ratings and Reviews
If you have been reading yourgoldiraguide reviews, you will know that we always highlight the ratings and reviews of a certain company. This is a metric that says a lot whether a company has good reputation or not.
- Better Business Bureau – B rating, not accredited
- Business Consumer Alliance – No rating available
- Trustpilot – 4.4 out 5 rating based on 65 reviews
As you can see, there is not much to say about Scottsdale Mint’s reviews. As I was browsing, most comments were about their shipping time, rip-offs, or orders being sent to another address.
It seems like there were no complaints about the products itself. Take a look at some screenshots I have gathered from the reviews in Trustpilot.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Free shipping for orders over $500
- Buyback availability
- No need for account creation
- They can buy back the metals you purchased
- Good inventory of products
Cons
- Does not offer IRA
- Few ratings and reviews
- Customer ratings weighs more on the negative side
- Fairly long shipment time
My Personal Verdict After 6 Months of Testing
After spending over $1,700 with Scottsdale Mint across multiple orders, my assessment is nuanced. This is absolutely a legitimate company producing high-quality products – the bullion I received was exceptional in every physical aspect.
However, the shipping delays are real and significant. If you’re comfortable with 2-4 week waits and prioritize product quality over speed, Scottsdale Mint delivers excellent value. I personally will use them again for specialty items and their Stacker series, which I haven’t found with comparable quality elsewhere.
But if you need bullion quickly, have tight investment timelines, or get anxious waiting for expensive packages, I’d recommend starting with faster competitors like APMEX or JM Bullion, despite their slightly lower product quality.
My Rating: 3.5/5 – Would be 4.5/5 if shipping matched industry standards.
Who Should Use Scottsdale Mint (Based on My Experience):
- Collectors who prioritize minting quality
- Long-term investors not concerned with 3-week delivery
- Buyers making large orders over $500 (free shipping offsets the wait)
Who Should Look Elsewhere:
- First-time buyers who want quick gratification
- Investors timing market dips requiring fast delivery
- Anyone uncomfortable with minimal tracking updates
