is goldeneaglecoin.com a scam

Welcome to my “Is Goldeneaglecoins.com A Scam” review!

(UPDATED January 2026)

When we talk about getting into gold or silver in 2026, it is very important to work with people who are trustworthy and to make sure that you are in great hands. Scams abound… look before you leap!

When acquiring precious metals, you need to work with the firm that fits your needs. However, that can be a challenge considering there more than a couple of them out there.

In this review, we shall go through Goldeneaglecoins.com and see if it is a company that you can trust or not. Are they legit? Or is Goldeneaglecoins.com a scam? Let’s find out.

Goldeneaglecoin.com Review Quick Summary

• Name: Golden Eagle Coins
• Founder and CEO: Bob Mangels Sr and Richard Stelfox
• Price: Varies
• Rating: 3/5

My Experience Researching Golden Eagle Coins as a Buyer

When I look at a precious metals dealer, I don’t just check how long they’ve been around. Longevity matters, but what really counts is how a company behaves when you’re actually trying to buy.

While researching Golden Eagle Coins, what stood out to me is that they operate like an old-school bullion dealer. No aggressive phone pressure, no “lock this price now or you’ll regret it” scare tactics. Their website is very transactional — you browse, you check prices, you place an order.

That’s not always exciting, but for some buyers, that’s exactly the point.

However, this also means you’re expected to know what you’re doing. This isn’t a hand-holding company. If you’re brand new to gold or IRAs, you may find the experience a bit cold compared to dealers that assign you a dedicated rep to walk you through everything step by step.

What is Golden Eagle Coins (Goldeneaglecoins.com)?

Let’s get to know this company first. Who are they?

Golden Eagle Coins is a precious metals company that provides its clients with various kinds of gold and silver bullion products.

Apart from that, there are collections of American Gold Eagle Coins, as well as bars and leafs that are available to be purchased.

Fun fact: In the year 1975, the U.S. government created the very first gold coins.

After 200 years, the first golden eagle coins were minted. Moreover, the U.S. congress gave authorization to these coins.

Basically, these coins hold a very historical value. Each of them possess great features. These include 50 stars, representing each state of the country, the Lady of Liberty’s image, and eagles which brings a patriotic message.

Moreover, these coins are 91% pure gold, 5.33% copper, 3% silver and are 22 karats. Golden Eagle Coins are the world’s leading bullion coins.

Golden Eagle Coins Sizes

Now, here are the different coin options that you can choose from:

By the way, face value is basically the legal value of the coin as an actual coin of the United States.

Why should someone acquire Golden Eagle Coins?

You might wonder why it is good to acquire Golden Eagle Coins. Well, unlike currency and stocks, these coins have maintained their value over time and through the years.

Moreover, it has been shown over time that these coins are very good at serving as a hedge against deflation and other market volatility and complications.

How to buy Golden Eagle Coins?

When purchasing Golden Eagle Coins, you can choose from 4 different types.

Each of these have a specific process for purchases. Here are they.

1. Proof Golden Eagle – you can get these coins from the United States Mint. When you buy them, you will also get a certificate of authentication and the coins are contained in a protective capsule. However, if you want to invest, you should not opt for this.
2. Bullion coins – you can purchase bullion coins from different precious metals and bullion companies around the U.S. They are also made for investors.
3. Circulating coins – just like how it is named, these coins are made for circulation but they are not delivered to the Federal Reserve Bank.
4. Uncirculated coins – these are made with an additional special process to make it good. Investors can buy them from United States Mint also.

Are there any IRAs?

Yes, Goldeneaglecoin.com offers IRAs. In fact, the Golden Eagle Coins meet the qualifications for IRAs.

This is why more and more people include Golden Eagle Coins in their IRA accounts.

And yes, you will have complete control on your IRAs since most of them are self-directed. To open a Gold IRA account, here are the steps:

1. Tell IRA custodian that you want to add Golden Eagle Coins.
2. Provide the information needed in the application form. Afterwards, you can add the precious metals.
3. Place your funds into your investments. Also, be sure that you won’t exceed the IRS limit for IRA contribution.
4. If you want to sell your precious metals, you only need to call your IRA custodian.

Also, if ever you have an existing IRA account, you can always have to option to have a rollover.

Transparency Check: What They Do Well (and What They Don’t)

One thing I always look for is whether a company hides behind vague language. Golden Eagle Coins doesn’t really do that when it comes to products, shipping, or payment methods. Prices are visible. Payment rules are clear. Shipping methods are spelled out.

Where transparency starts to weaken is on the IRA side.

If you’re buying coins outright, things are straightforward. But once IRAs enter the picture, you’re pushed toward custodians and third parties, and that’s where costs can quietly stack up. Storage fees, admin fees, and custodian charges aren’t clearly laid out upfront on the site.

That doesn’t mean anything shady is happening — it just means you need to ask questions before committing. Experienced investors usually do this automatically. First-timers often don’t.

IRA charges

Currently, the IRS only allows clients or investors to purchase a minimum of $5000 worth of Golden Eagle Coins.

If you plan on making more purchases, you have to make sure that the following orders you will make should be worth more than $1000.

Other fees are:

• Transaction fees
• Storage fees
• Commission fees
• Administration fees

Payment Methods

Golden Eagle Coins accepts various payment methods depending on the worth of your orders. Below you can see the payment methods, along their shipping time and order minimum and maximum.

1. Bank Wire Transfer – Order minimum of $2,500, no maximum order, ships 1 to 2 days.
2. Check (Personal/Bank) – Total order of $0 to $50,000, ships 10 banking days after receipt
3. Money Order – Total order of $0 to $10,000, ships 10 banking days after the receipt
4. Credit Card – Total order of $0 to $1,000, ships 1 to 5 days and must be to the billing address
5. Paypal – Total order of $0 to $25,000, ships 1 to 5 days and must be to the billing address​​​​
6. Cash – Total order of $0 to $10,000 but for local pickup only

Take note that Golden Eagle Coins does not charge any commission fees. However, you should notice that if you pay via Paypal or Credit Card, your prices are 4% more than the price if you pay via check, cash, bank wire or money order.

So I suggest that you take advantage of the cash-discounted payment methods to save money.

Shipping

All products are shipped via USPS insured mail. Furthermore, they are insured of their full value.

Packages that are worth $100, are delivered via First Class Mail. While packages that are worth $100 to $2000 are shipped via Priority Mail. Lastly, orders that are worth more than $2000 are shipped via Registered Mail.

Fed/Ex Ground is utilized for oversized or heavy items.

Below are the shipping charges.

• USPS Standard – FREE for orders over $99 ($9.95 for orders under $99)
• USPS Priority Mail – $14.95
• USPS Express Mail – $24.95 (Not available for credit card or Paypal orders)

Is Goldeneaglecoin.com (Golden Eagle Coins) a scam?

This is one of the commonly asked questions about this company. Goldeneaglecoin.com (Golden Eagle Coins) is  not a scam. It is a legit company that offers good products. Moreover, it has disclosed information about its founders and owners, including its address.

If it was a scam, then it would have been probably shut down. However, it has been in business for 46 years, remember?

Golden Eagle Coins Ratings (January 2026)

Below are the updated ratings and reviews of Goldeneaglecoin.com as of January 2026:

• BBB – A+ rating and BBB accredited since 2017 but there are no reviews available with 7 complaints closed in the last 3 years
• Trustpilot – 3.8 out of 5 rating based on 5,223 reviews
• Yelp – 2.7 out of 5 rating based on 21 reviews

Well, Golden Eagle Coins’ ratings and reviews are not that impressive if we compare them to other companies like Goldco.

If you are the type of investor who really values a company’s ratings and reviews, then you might consider other options.

Common Mistakes Buyers Make With Dealers Like This

I’ve seen people blame dealers for things that were really buyer mistakes, especially with hands-off companies like Golden Eagle Coins.

Some common ones:

• Not understanding premiums before buying

• Paying with credit cards and then complaining about higher prices

• Assuming IRA fees come from the dealer instead of the custodian

• Expecting instant shipping on check payments

None of these are unique to Golden Eagle Coins — but they show up more often when buyers don’t slow down and read the terms.

Precious metals reward patience. Rushing usually leads to disappointment.

Who Golden Eagle Coins Is Actually Best For

From everything I’ve seen, Golden Eagle Coins is best suited for a specific type of buyer:

• Someone who already understands bullion pricing

• Someone comfortable placing orders without sales guidance

• Someone who values product selection over concierge-style service

If you’re the kind of investor who wants a personal advisor checking in on you, explaining market moves, and structuring an IRA from scratch, this probably isn’t your ideal fit.

But if you already know what you want to buy and just want a reputable, no-nonsense dealer, Golden Eagle Coins can make sense.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• You can trust the company
• Been in business for over 46 years
• Offers great products
• You are given complete control
• Great customer support

Cons

• The IRA fees are not given on the website
• Very low BBB rating
• Lackluster Yelp rating

How Golden Eagle Coins Compares to Modern Gold IRA Companies

Compared to newer Gold IRA companies, Golden Eagle Coins feels more traditional.

Modern firms often focus on:

• Heavy education

• Emotional messaging

• “Protect your retirement now” narratives

Golden Eagle Coins focuses on:

• Inventory

• Execution

• Transactional buying

Neither approach is right or wrong — they just serve different personalities.

Personally, when it comes to retirement accounts, I lean toward companies that over-explain everything, even if it feels repetitive. That’s why many investors still prefer firms like Goldco or similar IRA-focused specialists.

Final Verdict

Let’s end this “Is Goldeneaglecoin.com A Scam?” review with my final verdict.

To be honest, this company seems legit. It provides excellent products and services. Moreover, its longevity is impressive.

But, it somehow lacks other information like the IRA fees. And yes, it did receive complaints from past clients and is given poor online ratings on BBB.

Final Trust Take From a Long-Term Perspective

A scam doesn’t survive decades. A scam doesn’t maintain consistent operations, insured shipping, and public ownership details for nearly half a century.

Golden Eagle Coins isn’t perfect, but nothing about its behavior raises red flags to me.

The key is alignment:

• If you want simplicity and selection → it works

• If you want guidance and structure → look elsewhere

That distinction alone saves investors a lot of frustration.

If you ask me, I would rather recommend a firm that is all-around great. You can check out my best recommendations here.

Thank you so much for reading my “Is Goldeneaglecoin.com a Scam?” review! If you have any comments or questions, feel free to leave them in the comments section.