Welcome to my Coins Plus Review.
(UPDATED January 2026)
If you are looking for a nice place to get your hands on high-quality precious metals and coins for your investment, you probably found this company.
But before you make any decisions, you should do your research and read this Coins Plus Review.
What are its products? Is it legit or a scam? You shall find out the answers right here. Let’s get started.
If you prefer to save time and just immediately want to know our TOP-RECOMMENDED precious metals company
Coins Plus Review Quick Summary
- Name: Coins Plus
- Owner: Kevin Wolter
- Price: Varies depending on your investments
- Rating: 3/5
What Real Customers Say After Actually Buying or Selling at Coins Plus
Coins Plus has a mix of loyal repeat customers and a few people who left frustrated, and the difference usually comes down to the exact situation, buying versus selling, and expectations around pricing.
On the positive side, several customers describe the shop as clean, professional, welcoming, and staffed by knowledgeable people who explain things well, especially for first time buyers. A few reviews even mention buying bullion and collectible coins over multiple years, which matters because repeat behavior is one of the strongest trust signals.
On the negative side, the most common complaints are about customer service tone, unexpected price outcomes, and a couple of people saying the shop was closed earlier than the posted hours, which is a big deal if you’re driving in from out of town.
What is Coins Plus?
Coins Plus is a precious metals and rare coins dealer that also offers depository services. It is commonly known as “the dealer’s dealer” because of its extensive selection of rare coins that they sell in high volumes.
Coins Plus offers gold, silver, platinum, and palladium coins and bars in various sizes and denominations. However, its products are primarily U.S. currencies and coins, which include commemorative coins and rare coins.
Furthermore, most of its products are IRA-eligible (e.g., American Gold Buffaloes and American Gold Eagles).
Coins Plus’ facility is established in Division Hill ClockTower Plaza, and the company has been serving investors and collectors in the Greater Northwest, United States, for over 10 years already.
Apart from their extensive product catalog, Coins Plus is a member of the following organizations:
- Independent Coin Grading Service (ICG)
- Pacific Northwest Numismatic Association (PNNA)
- Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS)
- Independent Council on Tangible Assets(ICTA)
- Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC)
- American Numismatic Association (ANA)
- Certified Coin Exchange (CCE)
- CoinNet (INI)
Coins Plus’ membership on these organizations says a lot about its reputation.
Coins Plus Management
Coins Plus is owned by the company’s president, Kevin Wolter, who is a professional and veteran financial adviser and precious metals specialist.
Moreover, he has more than a decade of experience as an executive of Fortune 100 financial institutions. Kevin is also trained and certified by the American Numismatic Association in advanced coin grading.
Under Kevin’s management and expertise in the industry, Coins Plus become one of the biggest coin dealers in the United States.
Coins Plus Products
Coins Plus offers a wide variety of gold and silver rare coins. Platinum and palladium items are also available.
The company mostly offers U.S. currency and coins. Coins Plus’ website has a product catalog wherein you can check the company’s products.
In Store Experience, Inventory, and the “Selection” Reality
A lot of reviewers mention a strong selection, and some specifically talk about buying numismatic and proof coins over time. That said, based on what people report, your experience may depend on what you’re looking for and when you visit.
If you’re hunting something specific, it’s smart to call first, confirm availability, and ask if they can hold it. A few customers mention long drives, so if you’re coming from outside Spokane, confirming hours and inventory ahead of time can save you frustration.
Some of the products included in their catalog are:
- Gold American Eagle Coins
- Gold US Saint-Gaudens $20
- Gold Canadian Maple Leaf Coins
- Silver 1-ozt .999-Fine Rounds
- Silver 100-ozt .999-Fine Bars
- U.S. Copper-Half Cents & Large Cents
- Platinum American Eagles
There are still a lot of products listed in the website. For those of you wondering, yes, they also offer IRA-eligible precious metals.
HOWEVER, when I checked the availability of the products, most of them are out of stock. So if you are interested in availing Coins Plus products, you can try contacting them and confirm if they have any products available.
How to buy from Coins Plus?
Since Coins Plus’ website allows its clients to order online, you can make an account there where you can add products to your cart and proceed to the payment.
It is pretty much similar to the common e-commerce websites we have out there.
However, there is a lack of information regarding the buying process. My best bet is to just order online or you can give them a call.
What the Buying Process Feels Like for Real People
If you’re new to precious metals, multiple customer stories describe Coins Plus as the kind of place where staff will answer beginner questions and help you choose a first purchase. Some buyers say they felt respected even when they weren’t spending huge amounts, which is exactly what you want from a local dealer.
At the same time, a couple of people describe interactions that felt rushed or disrespectful, so if you’re the type who wants a calm, patient experience, it’s worth going in with a clear plan, and if the vibe is off, simply leave and compare with another dealer.
Selling to Coins Plus
Apart from buying precious metals and coins, you can also sell to Coins Plus. Currently, they are accepting jewelry, scrap gold, silver, gold, coins and currency, platinum and palladium.
You only need to contact Coins Plus to notify them that you would like to sell precious metals or coins to them. Or you can also visit their facility.
The prices may vary depending on the market. However, the website has a page on which you can check the current sale price of various coins and precious metals.
Unfortunately, there are also not much information about the process. Your best bet is to just contact them.
Selling to Coins Plus, Read This Before You Hand Over Anything
Selling is where most misunderstandings happen in any coin shop, and Coins Plus is no exception.
Some sellers say they felt the offer was not fair compared to other local shops, and one person specifically mentioned getting a meaningfully better offer a few blocks away. Another reviewer said they later felt “ripped off” after selling.
That doesn’t automatically mean the company is shady, it usually means the seller didn’t compare enough offers or didn’t fully understand how the shop was calculating buy prices at that moment.
If you’re selling, do this like a pro:
Get at least 2 to 3 quotes in Spokane the same day, ask the shop to explain the buy price relative to spot, and don’t sell on the spot if you feel pressured or confused.
Safe Depository Service
Other than its precious metals and coins, Coins Plus also speaks highly of its state-of-the-art safe depository service.
They guarantee to provide the best and most secure depository services to its clients. Based on the website, you only need to fill up a form to avail this service.
Moreover, the prices vary depending on the size of the deposit box. Below, you can see the costs.
Shipping and Payment Methods
Usually, precious metal companies disclose information on their payment methods and shipping process on their websites.
This is to make sure that clients are aware of the processes and the whereabouts of their orders.
But Coins Plus failed to put this on their website. Clients may only know when they contact the company.
Before You Drive There, Confirm These 3 Things
A couple of people mentioned showing up when they expected the shop to be open and finding it closed, including someone who said they drove a long distance.
To avoid that situation, here’s a simple move that protects you:
Call ahead the same day and confirm:
-
They are open right now,
-
the staff member confirms the posted closing time,
-
they confirm the exact item and price range you’re coming for.
This takes 60 seconds and prevents wasted trips.
Does it offer IRA services?
Currently, Coins Plus does not offer any IRA services, nor is it partnered with IRA custodians.
If you wish to open an IRA account, you can check out Goldco, which is the leading precious metals IRA company today.
Coins Plus Ratings and Reviews
Here in Your Gold IRA Guide, we always give importance to a company’s ratings and reviews. These give us an idea or a perspective of past clients towards the services and products of the company.
The higher the ratings and more positive reviews, the better. This also mirrors the reputation of the companies.
With that being said, at the time of writing this Coins Plus Review, I found the following online ratings and reviews of the company.
- BBB – 4 out of 5 rating, A+ rating, BBB accredited, based on 4 reviews
- BCA – AA rating, no reviews and complaints
- Yellowpages – 5/5 rating based on 14 reviews
- Yelp – 3.5/5 rating based on 14 reviews
Although Coins Plus has high ratings, it only has a small number of reviews. Moreover, the ratings are based on these few reviews.
Patterns Inside the Reviews, What Repeats and What It Means
When you scan the reviews, a few patterns repeat.
Repeated positives:
Knowledgeable staff, friendly atmosphere, strong selection, and people who feel comfortable buying there again.
Repeated negatives:
Customer service tone, pricing expectations, and a few stories about communication that felt disrespectful.
The key takeaway is simple, Coins Plus seems to perform best for buyers who know what they want, ask clear questions, and verify pricing and inventory ahead of time. If you’re selling, it’s even more important to shop around.
Compared to other companies like Goldco, Coins Plus falls short on this.
Coins Plus Pros and Cons
Pros
- Wide range of products
- Expert staff and owner
- Good online ratings and reviews
- Can order online
- Offers good safe depository services
- Member of several numismatic organizations
Cons
- Lacks reviews from review sites
- No IRA services
- Website lacks information
- Most products are out of stock
My Practical Verification Checklist Before Trusting Any Local Coin Dealer
Even if a dealer is legitimate, you still want to protect yourself.
Here’s the checklist I recommend before you spend serious money:
-
Ask for the exact price relative to spot, and what premium you’re paying
-
Ask if the product is bullion or collectible, and why
-
Confirm buyback policy, even if you don’t plan to sell soon
-
If selling, get 2 to 3 quotes, no exceptions
-
Keep receipts and product details for your records
This is how serious buyers avoid regrets, no drama, no emotions, just clean decision making.
Is Coins Plus a scam?
To conclude this Coins Plus Review, let me give my answer on this question.
Coins Plus is not a scam. It is a legitimate and genuine rare coins dealer with good services and products.
Moreover, its staff and the owner are all experts in the industry. Coins Plus garnered good ratings online, but still lack reviews from other review sites.
Although the company is good, it still has a lot to cover to be able to compete against the industry’s top and leading precious metals companies.
If you wish to know my top recommendation, check it out below.
Thank you so much for reading my Coins Plus Review! If you have any comments or questions, feel free to leave them in the comments section.
